What are the potential cost savings of DIY weed and feed application compared to hiring a professional in my area?

DIY application can save you money upfront, potentially around $19 per application for a 5000 sq ft lawn, as you avoid labor costs and service fees. However, you'll need to factor in the cost of materials, equipment (like a spreader), and your own time. Professional services in cities like New York, NY can range from $75-$287 for a 1/4-acre lot.

What are the pros and cons of applying weed and feed myself?

DIY pros include cost savings and flexibility in scheduling. However, cons include the time and effort required, the need for proper knowledge and technique to avoid damaging your lawn, and the lack of guarantees if something goes wrong.

What are the benefits of hiring a professional weed and feed service?

Professional services offer expertise in identifying weed types and selecting appropriate treatments, access to commercial-grade products, and proper timing for effective application and prevention. They also save you time and effort, and many offer guarantees or free service calls to address any issues.

Is weed and feed as effective as separate fertilizer and weed killer applications?

Generally, weed and feed products are considered less effective than applying fertilizer and weed killer separately, as they may not address specific nutrient needs or target particular weed types effectively. Professionals often recommend tailored programs with separate applications for optimal results.

What are the potential risks of DIY weed and feed application?

Risks of DIY application include improper application leading to lawn damage (e.g., fertilizer burn), ineffective weed control, potential harm to the environment from incorrect chemical usage, and health risks if products are not handled safely. Additionally, early application of high-nitrogen weed and feed can damage lawns.

DIY vs Pro Weed & Feed: Costs

By Home Sidekick Team May 30, 2025 8 min read 1692 words

DIYlawn careweed and feedcost analysisprofessional services[City/Region]

Maintaining a lush, green lawn can be a source of pride and a welcoming sight. But the battle against weeds and the quest for healthy grass often leads homeowners to a crucial decision: Do it yourself (DIY) or hire a professional? When it comes to weed and feed treatments, both options have their pros and cons, particularly when considering the costs involved. This comprehensive guide breaks down the expenses, labor, and potential benefits of each approach, helping you make an informed decision for your lawn.

Understanding Weed and Feed

Before diving into the cost comparison, it's important to understand what weed and feed is and why it's used. Weed and feed is a combination product containing both herbicides (to kill weeds) and fertilizers (to nourish grass). It's designed to be applied in one application, saving time and effort compared to applying each separately.

Herbicides: These chemicals target and kill unwanted weeds like dandelions, clover, and crabgrass.
Fertilizers: These provide essential nutrients like nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium, promoting healthy grass growth.

Weed and feed products are typically granular, designed to be spread evenly across your lawn. The timing of application is crucial for effectiveness, often recommended in the spring or fall when weeds are actively growing and grass is receptive to nutrients.

DIY Weed and Feed: A Detailed Cost Breakdown

Taking the DIY route can seem like a cost-effective way to manage your lawn. However, it's essential to consider all the potential expenses involved.

Upfront Costs

Weed and Feed Product: The primary cost is the weed and feed itself. Prices vary based on brand, coverage area, and the specific weed-killing and fertilizing properties. Expect to pay between $20 to $100+ per bag, covering anywhere from 5,000 to 15,000 square feet. For example, Scotts Turf Builder Weed & Feed can cost around $30-$50 for a bag that covers 5,000 sq ft. (Source: Home Depot, Lowe's websites)
Spreader: If you don't already own one, you'll need a spreader to apply the weed and feed evenly. A basic broadcast spreader can cost $30-$50, while a drop spreader may range from $50-$100. (Source: Amazon)
Protective Gear: Safety is paramount. Gloves ($5-$10) and possibly eye protection ($10-$20) are necessary to protect yourself from chemical exposure.
Weed Puller/Hand Tools: Even with weed and feed, some persistent weeds may require manual removal. A basic weed puller costs $15-$30.

Ongoing Costs

Repeat Applications: Weed and feed typically requires multiple applications per year (usually spring and fall). Budget for purchasing additional bags of product.
Watering: Proper watering is essential after applying weed and feed to activate the chemicals and help the fertilizer penetrate the soil. Increased water bills should be factored in, especially during drier months.
Spot Treatments: Some stubborn weeds may require separate spot treatments with liquid herbicides, adding to your overall costs. A bottle of liquid herbicide can range from $10-$30.
Soil Testing (Optional): To ensure you're using the right type of fertilizer, a soil test is recommended. DIY soil test kits cost around $20-$40. Professional soil testing services can range from $50-$150. (Source: Local extension offices, universities)

Hidden Costs

Time and Labor: Your time is valuable. Applying weed and feed, watering, and dealing with any issues takes time and effort.
Mistakes and Re-dos: Applying too much or the wrong type of weed and feed can damage your lawn, leading to additional costs for reseeding or repair.
Storage: Storing leftover weed and feed product safely requires adequate space and proper containers.

Example: Let's say you have a 5,000 sq ft lawn. You purchase a bag of weed and feed for $40, a spreader for $40, gloves for $10, and a weed puller for $20. Your upfront cost is $110. If you apply weed and feed twice a year, your annual cost for the product alone is $80. Adding in water costs and potential spot treatments, your total annual DIY cost could range from $150-$250.

Professional Weed and Feed: A Detailed Cost Breakdown

Hiring a professional lawn care service offers convenience and expertise, but it also comes with a price tag. Understanding the costs involved is crucial for making an informed decision.

Service Packages

Lawn care companies typically offer various service packages, ranging from basic weed and feed applications to comprehensive lawn care programs that include fertilization, weed control, aeration, and pest control. The cost depends on the size of your lawn, the services included, and the frequency of treatments.

Cost Factors

Lawn Size: Larger lawns will naturally cost more to treat.
Number of Treatments: Most companies recommend multiple treatments throughout the year (4-7 applications) for optimal results.
Type of Treatment: Specialized treatments, such as grub control or disease control, will increase the overall cost.
Company Reputation and Expertise: Established companies with experienced technicians may charge more than newer or less reputable services.
Geographic Location: Lawn care costs can vary depending on your region and the local market rates.

Average Costs

Single Weed and Feed Application: A single application of weed and feed can range from $50 to $150, depending on lawn size and company rates.
Basic Lawn Care Package (Weed Control & Fertilization): An annual package including regular weed control and fertilization can cost between $300 to $800. (Source: Thumbtack, HomeAdvisor)
Comprehensive Lawn Care Package (Including Aeration, Overseeding, Pest Control): A comprehensive package can range from $800 to $2000 or more per year.

Example: For a 5,000 sq ft lawn, a basic lawn care package with 5 weed and feed applications could cost around $500-$700 per year. This includes the cost of the product, labor, and expertise.

Benefits Beyond Cost

Expertise and Knowledge: Professionals have the knowledge to identify specific weed and grass types, soil conditions, and pest problems, allowing them to tailor treatments for optimal results.
Time Savings: You save significant time and effort by outsourcing your lawn care.
Proper Application: Professionals use calibrated equipment and precise application techniques to ensure even coverage and avoid over-application, which can damage your lawn.
Guaranteed Results: Many lawn care companies offer guarantees, promising to re-treat your lawn if you're not satisfied with the results.
Convenience: Scheduled treatments ensure consistent lawn care without you having to worry about purchasing products or finding the time to apply them.

DIY vs. Pro: A Side-by-Side Comparison Table

To help you visualize the differences, here's a comparison table summarizing the key aspects of DIY and professional weed and feed.

Feature	DIY Weed and Feed	Professional Weed and Feed
Cost	Lower upfront cost, but potential for hidden costs and re-dos.	Higher upfront cost, but predictable and potentially cost-effective in the long run.
Time and Effort	Requires significant time and effort for application, watering, and maintenance.	Minimal time and effort required.
Expertise	Requires research and knowledge of weed and grass types, soil conditions, and application techniques.	Provided by trained and experienced professionals.
Equipment	Requires purchasing or renting a spreader and other tools.	Equipment is provided by the lawn care company.
Results	Results depend on your knowledge, skills, and the quality of the product.	Results are typically guaranteed.
Convenience	Inconvenient, requires planning and execution.	Highly convenient, scheduled treatments.

Making the Right Choice for Your Lawn

The decision between DIY and professional weed and feed ultimately depends on your budget, time availability, expertise, and desired results. Consider the following factors when making your choice:

Your Budget: Assess your financial situation and determine how much you're willing to spend on lawn care.
Your Time: Evaluate how much time you can dedicate to lawn care tasks.
Your Expertise: Honestly assess your knowledge and skills in lawn care.
Your Desired Results: Determine what level of lawn quality you're aiming for.

When DIY Might Be the Better Option

You're on a tight budget.
You enjoy lawn care and have the time to dedicate to it.
You have a small lawn that's relatively easy to manage.
You're comfortable researching and learning about lawn care techniques.

When Professional Lawn Care Might Be the Better Option

You're willing to invest in professional services for convenience and guaranteed results.
You have a large or complex lawn that requires specialized treatments.
You lack the time or expertise to manage your lawn effectively.
You want to achieve a consistently healthy and beautiful lawn.

Tips for Saving Money on Lawn Care (Regardless of Your Choice)

Whether you choose DIY or professional lawn care, there are several ways to save money and maximize the effectiveness of your treatments.

DIY Tips

Buy in Bulk: Purchase weed and feed in larger quantities to save money per application.
Shop Around: Compare prices from different retailers to find the best deals.
Apply Correctly: Follow the product instructions carefully to avoid over-application or wasted product.
Water Efficiently: Water your lawn deeply and infrequently to promote healthy root growth and reduce water bills.
Maintain Your Equipment: Keep your spreader and other tools in good condition to ensure proper application.

Professional Tips

Get Multiple Quotes: Obtain quotes from several lawn care companies to compare prices and services.
Negotiate: Don't be afraid to negotiate the price or ask for discounts.
Choose the Right Package: Select a service package that meets your specific needs and budget.
Ask About Guarantees: Ensure the company offers a guarantee on their services.
Maintain Your Lawn: Follow the company's recommendations for watering, mowing, and other maintenance practices to maximize the effectiveness of the treatments.

Conclusion: Investing in a Beautiful Lawn

The cost of weed and feed, whether DIY or professional, is an investment in the health and appearance of your lawn. By carefully considering the factors outlined in this guide, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your budget, time, and desired results. Whether you choose to tackle the task yourself or entrust it to a professional, a well-maintained lawn provides numerous benefits, from increasing your property value to creating a welcoming outdoor space for your family and friends.

Next Steps:

If considering DIY, research weed and feed products suitable for your grass type and common weeds. Consider performing a soil test to determine nutrient deficiencies.
If considering professional lawn care, get quotes from at least three local companies. Ask about their experience, guarantees, and treatment methods.
No matter which route you choose, create a lawn care schedule and stick to it for optimal results.